Strip Shingles Vs. Architectural Shingles: Factors to Consider

Shingles are a common roofing material in American homes. The two main asphalt choices among homeowners are strip or three-tab and architectural shingles. You can decide which one is right for you if you know how the two compare.

This blog explores vital information you need to choose the best shingles type for your roof.

Cost

The buying price of strip shingles is lower than architectural shingles. Also, because strip shingles are lighter, installation is easier and less costly. So, strip shingles are a great option if your budget is tight.

Unfortunately, the costs may catch up with you because strip shingles need higher

maintenance. Architectural shingles are 20% more expensive but give you more life and a longer warranty.

Further, the installation costs vary based on different needs. For instance, the demand for installation renovation is high during spring and summer. So, the installation costs rise.

Other factors like roof slope also determine the costs. Either way, strip shingles are more affordable in the short run.

Appearance

Strip shingles are flat and have a single tab size and shape. The uniformity gives strip shingles a flat or matte look. Despite the simplicity, strip shingles have many color options. So, you can always find one to complement different home styles.

Architectural shingles have several layers of materials that give your roof a more dimensional look. Also, architectural shingles offer greater versatility in shape and size.

The material can mimic more expensive roofing types like cedar shakes or slate. As a result, your home gets a more luxurious look that adds to the curb appeal.

Durability and Longevity

Strip shingles have one layer of material that makes your roof thin. The expected lifespan of strip shingles is 15 to 20 years under optimal conditions. Yet, if your roof faces constant

exposure to harsh elements, the average period can reduce to 10 years.

The durability and high-quality composition boost the lifespan of architectural shingles. For instance, the ceramic granules on the shingles improve your roof's lifespan. So, if you use architectural shingles, your roof stands up better to harsh conditions.

The architectural lifespan is 20 years in extreme situations. Nonetheless, the roof may last up to 30 years under optimal conditions.

Material and Wind Warranty

Strip shingles have a shorter lifespan than architectural shingles. Therefore, strip shingles have lower warranties. For the standard wind warranty, you can expect a wind speed rating of 60 MPH, which you can upgrade to 80 MPH if you add extra nails and glue to the shingles.

The longer expected lifespan of architectural shingles translates to more extended warranties. Some architectural shingle roof warranties cover a few decades. Some contractors also offer lifetime warranties, which equates to 50 years.

The basic wind warranty for architectural shingles is 110 MPH, but you can upgrade it to 130 or 150 MPH.

Architectural shingles are ideal if you are a high-end homeowner who prioritizes aesthetics. Choose architectural shingles if you live in a region facing hurricanes, floods, and blizzards. Conversely, strip shingles are the way to go if you prefer a vintage roof look. Also, if you have a weaker structure, strip shingles are better as the material is lighter than architectural shingles.

Ultimately, the type of shingles you will install depends on your personal preferences and budget. At Classic Remodeling, we offer quality asphalt roofing materials and professionals to install or replace your roof. Contact us today to start your journey to quality and durable roofs. We will be happy to answer your questions and concerns and help you make the right decision for your home. Let us know how we can help you.